+update+
March 27. 2019
After some DMCA action on my behalf, the list of websites using Shopify or Etsy as a platform are taking down the AT-AT Landscape one-by-one. A total of 48 (!) pages with counterfeit offers are gone by the end of this day.
Etsy listing 1 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/578220591/star-wars-at-at...
Etsy Listing 2 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/533999100/star-wars-blechschild...
Etsy Listing 3 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/567770127/star-wars-in-art-star...
Etsy Listing 4 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/563949452/at-at-5-panel-stuck-lei...
Etsy Listing 5 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/540956089/at-at-leinwand-leinwa...
Etsy Listing 6 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/548140924/star-wars-inspiriert...
Etsy Listing 7 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/519135613/star-wars-an-in-kunst...
Etsy Listing 8 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/562697157/star-wars-movie-at-at...
Etsy Listing 9 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/568122030/front-kunst-imperial-wa...
Etsy Listing 10 https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/493051239/star-wars-imperial-wal...
Etsy Listing 11
https://www.etsy.com/de/listing/581950379/at-at-star-wars-leinwa...
Amazon - www.amazon.com
canvasfreaks - www.canvasfreaks.com
EpicKanvas - www.epickanvas.com
itmakeyourday - www.itmakeyourday.com
thrillingcanvas - www.thrillingcanvas.com
roomframes - www.room-frames.com
printartizans - www.printartizans.com
Nerdsusstore - www.nerdsrusstore.com
WookieStore -
www.wookiestore.com
canvasfrenzy - www.canvasfrenzy.com
theforcegallery - www.theforcegallery.com
Printgaze - www.printgaze.com
Canvart - www.canvart.co
panelwallart - www.panelwallart.com
fanrepublic - www.fanrepublic.myshopify.com
Teepeat - www.teepeat.com
wallofstarwars - www.wallofstarwars.com
thewallartgallery - www.thewallartgallery.com
Empire Prints - www.empire-prints.com
Geek-Bling - www.geek-bling.com
Superhacks - www.superhacks.net
Artfire - www.artfire.com
moosemunchcreationss - www.moosemunchcreations.ca
Geekpaintings - https://geekpaintings.com/artis...
calybur - www.calybur.com
Wanelo - www.wanelo.co
BKC Direct - www.bkcdirect.com
Wish.com - www.Wish.com
Ebay Ca - www.ebay.ca
Ebay US - www.ebay.com
AT-ST on Ebay - www.ebay.com
Spikeybits - www.spikeybits.com
AIO-Hacks 2 - aiohacks.net (Howl's castle 3 panel rip-off)
AIO-Hacks 1 - aoihacks.net (Howl's castle 1 panel rip-off)
AIO-Hacks 3 - aiohacks.net (Howl's castle 5 panel rip-off)
Ligitoch - www.ligitoch.com
- 26stee - www.26stee.com (Laputa in the Sky over Achensee rip-off)
It definitely feels good to be able doing something. It is bad that you have to make it part of your business and if you don't do it, no one else will, but knowledge is everything ;)If you are on my side, watch the list growing...
December 20. 2017
There is now a dozen sites more where this counterfeit work of the AT-AT as 5 panel canvas is being sold.
Please beware of the following websites in general. They used my low-res version wallpaper to sell large prints and the quality is dot-matrix-printer like, so you can bet that your favorite other work will be of similar sub-standard quality from china. Please do yourself a favor and don't order with these shopping websites, this is not my work you support and you will get lowest standard print quality:
troopermart - www.troopermart.com - Attorney / Pixsy
Amazon - www.amazon.fr - dmca sent
AliExpress - www.aliexpress.com IPR verification in progress
Cdiscount - www.cdiscount.com - Attorney
woodypink - www.woodypink.com - Attorney
homenall - www.homenall.com - Attorney
Update 2 - 2017:
Yesterday I reported several offers on Etsy and they were all taken down. From now on, I will have a monthly look about the platform and collect offers to send them a legal inquiry every end of the month from now. Same on Amazon and ebay.
+update end for 2017+
Since it was brought to my attention from 2 different awesome people that my Bierstadt/Star-Wars homage was sold by Primelinegear , Teepeat and most recently Empire Prints and Printgaze without consent, I felt the need to write something about these shopping sites as this is real business and it tends to get worse when people are not in the know.
Please note, the site primelinegear com serves as an educational example here, the points mentioned below should work for any subject and web shop you will stumble upon.
I have to say that the piece itself which can be found as a wallpaper here, is not meant to be sold on the internet. Not on zazzle, not on deviantArt not on Society6 - for the main reason that they have trained staff of people who just crawl the user submitted content and pull down everything that refers in any way to Disney or Lucasfilm, etc.
If it appears anywhere else than on a Wallpaper site, it is most likely not authorized. And if people sell it, they do it at their own risk.To make your Christmas shopping a bit more safe, here are some ways to spot a fraudulent site or offers if you are unsure.
Following is a list of questions you can ask yourself if a site is legit or not:
Amazon- www.amazon.com
It definitely feels good to be able doing something. It is bad that you have to make it part of your business and if you don't do it, no one else will, but knowledge is everything ;)If you are on my side, watch the list growing...
December 20. 2017
There is now a dozen sites more where this counterfeit work of the AT-AT as 5 panel canvas is being sold.
Please beware of the following websites in general. They used my low-res version wallpaper to sell large prints and the quality is dot-matrix-printer like, so you can bet that your favorite other work will be of similar sub-standard quality from china. Please do yourself a favor and don't order with these shopping websites, this is not my work you support and you will get lowest standard print quality:
troopermart - www.troopermart.com - Attorney / Pixsy
Amazon - www.amazon.fr - dmca sent
AliExpress - www.aliexpress.com IPR verification in progress
Cdiscount - www.cdiscount.com - Attorney
woodypink - www.woodypink.com - Attorney
homenall - www.homenall.com - Attorney
Update 2 - 2017:
Yesterday I reported several offers on Etsy and they were all taken down. From now on, I will have a monthly look about the platform and collect offers to send them a legal inquiry every end of the month from now. Same on Amazon and ebay.
+update end for 2017+
Since it was brought to my attention from 2 different awesome people that my Bierstadt/Star-Wars homage was sold by Primelinegear , Teepeat and most recently Empire Prints and Printgaze without consent, I felt the need to write something about these shopping sites as this is real business and it tends to get worse when people are not in the know.Please note, the site primelinegear com serves as an educational example here, the points mentioned below should work for any subject and web shop you will stumble upon.
I have to say that the piece itself which can be found as a wallpaper here, is not meant to be sold on the internet. Not on zazzle, not on deviantArt not on Society6 - for the main reason that they have trained staff of people who just crawl the user submitted content and pull down everything that refers in any way to Disney or Lucasfilm, etc.
If it appears anywhere else than on a Wallpaper site, it is most likely not authorized. And if people sell it, they do it at their own risk.To make your Christmas shopping a bit more safe, here are some ways to spot a fraudulent site or offers if you are unsure.
Following is a list of questions you can ask yourself if a site is legit or not:
Is the artist mentioned?
Tricky situation on this one here because if the site was legit, they would mention at least Albert Bierstadt, Dimitri Kaliviotis, Industrial Light & Magic and my humble self.
Red Flag #1 Set!
Also the counter sets itself back after the time went down. There is no way I could trust this site and that is a bad reputation for the whole business.
Red Flag #2 Set!
You can easily check if the offer is real by waiting for the countdown clock to run out. No worries, if a simple site refresh makes the stock full again, it is highly possible that the offer is still there when the countdown has expired.
Red Flag #3 Set!
Get real feedback | what others say
I had the luck that a loyal supporter fb friend mentioned me in this post from It's Dark Side Thing where you can spot some immediate feedback about their bad check-out experience (just put top comments first)
Either my DCMA report has worked and they just keep the offer on their site to tease people or it is THE scam it seems to be.
Not easy to find this kind of feedback, in this case it helps to find facebook related pages that are legit and watch those items and their commentsections before you plunge into the X-Mas shopping season. Red Flag #5 Set!
Proof for a Case
Btw. since comments might be deleted, I will keep snapshots from facebook comments as they appear for documentation. But to save privacy, I refrain from posting them here, let me know if you want them for a case, lawsuit, etc.
Personally I refrain from getting a lawyer involved, as these kinda businesses seem hard to catch, chances are very cloudy and time spent - in no relation to a return.
With this blog post I can use their bad for something good.
Final Words TL:DR
Finally this is about YOUR money, if it is a lot money, these simple steps won't take you long but can save you bad feelings and money.
If your desire and budget is high there is hope that this article might find you before you blow money out of the open window.
Another point is that most nerds or geeks are eager to support the artists directly, bad cards for seller who don´t give a shit about artists. Wrong market. These sites come and go.
Real artists are here to stay.
If you still want that AT-AT piece...
You can go to my deviantArt page and download the Wallpaper, its essentially the same file Prime Line Gear uses, so the quality might be the same when you go to your local printer.
Edit Dec. 2016:
Apparently, the method is not just limited to one site only, as the site Teepeat .com uses the exact same image and site to boot: https://teepeat.com/products/at-at
Only a less original logo on the upper left suggests that this is a different page.
And they use the exact same post on facebook to promote the product via it's a dark side thing:
PayPal refunds:
One loyal person who ordered via PayPal got back to me with some hopefully helpful information, regarding a refund:
"I contacted paypal the other day and they said if articles are not genuine you have grounds to dispute a payment. I disputed it on these grounds and within a day prime line issued me a refund. It currently shows on my paypal account. I'll have to wait and see if it actually makes it through to my account, but its good to know that if anyone has bought any of this stuff via paypal they are entitled to dispute it, and it seems prime line wont even put up a fight. I just said that it was poor quality, and also believed to be counterfeit as it breached copyright laws."
Thank you. Very valuable blog.
ReplyDeleteGreetings from Germany. Oliver
Thanks for the blog post. Stopped me from buying this, even though I love the artwork itself. Great job on it. Just out of curiosity, are you able to sell this piece of work, and if so, how would one purchase it from you, instead of this fly-by-night scam website?
ReplyDeleteHi, I´m glad you found this article useful!
DeleteSince I got many inquiries over the past weeks, I added some options at the very bottom of the article on where to get the AT-AT piece.
Please understand, since I´m in a grey-area with the work itself, I have to limit availability to stay in a green spot. If there will be other options in the future, they will be added here.
Thanks for reading,
best, Oliver
Great piece!
DeleteThank you for debunking this scam just before I clicked Buy! I promised my son his choice of "5 panel Star Wars poster" for Christmas, and your work was his immediate choice.
I'd still like to "buy" this for him. I downloaded your wallpaper version (thank you!) but would you consider offering a higher resolution for me to print at BayPhoto (or similar company)? I'd like to return the favor by making a donation (but not a royalty, because then that might put you in a grayer area!).
Thanks! steven AT-AT kan dot org.
@Steven Kan I sent you an email but your mail quota is full ;)
DeleteI have found an option to make limited downloads available upon request, please get in touch via my contact form http://www.fantasio.info/p/contact.html
With a working email address I can forward the option to you.
Thanks again for your comment and I'm glad you found this article helpful.
Best,
Oliver
I unfortunately got scammed... :( I did have a bad feeling, but got SO excited about the work that I lost my senses and just placed the order without thinking it through. I just really LOVE it to bits!
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry I helped them profit from using your intellectual property :( ...Also I'm pretty damn sorry and angry for myself, because that money was A LOT to me :(
I would still REALLY want to get a print of some sort, but now probably can't afford one for a while :( But would it be possible to buy it from you in digital format in a bigger size (bigger than the desktop wallpaper).
Thanks!
Hi, how did it went for you? Did they just charge your card and you got nothing in return or did you at least got what you ordered?
DeleteI believe it might help others who stumble about this article and fear their money is lost.
From my end, I have to say I see it realistic and to some extent it is promotion/advertising for my work that I could not afford otherwise.
Other than that, I´m on my way to a convention, for more information please send me an email through the contact form. A reply might take a few days now though. Thanks.
Oliver
I also got scammed:'( Fell SO stupid. Over $60 just gone!
DeleteI got scammed too I bought 2 prints and never got anything in return :( I paid by card and I really wish I had saw this post before I lost a lot of money.
DeleteDamn bro, thx for typing this blog! I felt suspiscious but almost bought 2 of those sets.. Thank god I Found this.
ReplyDeleteStop me just in time I was looking for discount coupons when stumble on this.
ReplyDeleteAlso bought this print for my son for Xmas. The reply email they sent looked a little strange and after not hearing anything further from them, I tried to contact them without any success. When you hit the order status icon, it just time you out. Which is how I came to see this article. Thank you so much for writing this,and want to say how much I enjoyed looking at your website. I contacted my credit card company and, luckily, they are going to remove the charge. Over a hundred dollars is a lot to lose at this time of the year, or at anytime for that matter. Will definitely be ordering straight from the artist from now on.
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot for sharing your experience with us, I hope it helps others as well. I´m glad you enjoyed the site and found this article just in time. All the best and a happy holiday season!
DeleteOliver
I also got caught up in this scam. Ordered the framed print for my son. When I went on their site to check the status, the tracking icon just times out or says page no longer exists. I now have learned a lesson, to investigate the company further. Luckily, my credit card company is going to give us a credit. Thank you for writing this article!
ReplyDeleteI also ordered the print from them. I tried to get an order number via their site and like others stated, it times out always. A few days ago I got a message from them on Facebook providing an order # and a tracking number. The shipment is coming from China. There has been no update on the shipping other than the acceptance of the request. Waiting to see what happens next.
ReplyDeleteI'm waiting to see if anything comes of this before I go try to claim fraud either through Bank or Amazon Payments. If I lose out on the money its a lesson learned.
I did notice on one of their Facebook posts however they gave another person a tracking number and a link to track it, but when clicked it states the tracking number is invalid.
I wrote the previous thread and had been trying for two weeks to get some answers. If you look closely at the number provided, it isn't a legitimate phone number, missing a digit.
DeleteSo I ended up filing an claim with Amazon payments in January. I was refunded by them at the end of January. Here it is the end of February, and I had put this whole thing behind me. Suddenly, today, I receive the prints in the mail.
DeleteHave not opened it yet, as I'm not sure about keeping or sending back. However looking for their site, it appears to be gone. The website has disappeared.
As it had been months with nothing, and tracking provided had not changed in almost 2 months, I had requested a refund via Amazon Payments in January. By end of January I had received the refund. I thought this whole episode was over however today the prints suddenly showed up.
DeleteI have not opened the package yet as I am conflicted with sending back or not. However, trying to look up their site, I find it is no longer there. It appears the website is gone.
So when I saw this item in my facebook news feed, I immediately started googling for scams.
ReplyDeleteCouldn't find any bad stuff, and I didn't expect that facebook would shove suggested post advertisement into my face when they are fraudulent.
Site being amazon and paypal verified according to themselves, I bought it with Amazon.
I ordered this item on the 23rd of November, so before this post was written.
No items have been sent to me yet, and I cannot get my order details either because the site times out, but only when I try to look up my order.
Today I got another similar advertisement in my facebook feed, from another site selling similar canvas paintings.
I've now filed a claim with Amazon as a result.
Broken dreams :(
I bought one of these canvases and they took the money out of my account on the 2nd of december. Ive tried contacting them to see if I could track my item but when it sent me to a china tracking website I kinda realized I got scammed. If I call my bank and tell them it was fraud would they return my money? Please anyone who knows help me out. I shouldve researched the company a bit more but Ive learned my lesson thus far. As of now Im just trying to get my money back so if anyone knows how/if its possible to get my money back that would be great!
ReplyDeleteSo, have people at least be receiving what they purchased? Or is it just a big scam and getting nothing in return?
ReplyDeleteI ordered a print off these at the beginning of November, they have sent me a tracking number. Sometimes it works and it tells where it is being shipped to other times the tracking doesn't work. I have sent a message to them on the ask a question part and they said it should be here shortly. I really don't know what to think anymore
ReplyDeleteI ordered from Prime Line back on the 17th of November... started looking into this issue when I hadn't received any notice of it being shipped. The "look up your order" actually worked a few times (like just bringing up a cached webpage) but never said fulfilled. Got anxious and Googled Prime Line Gear and found this article. Thankfully, I used Amazon Payment and was able to submit a claim ... I cited this article in the claim, as well as sending an email to their "support" address with a demand for cancel/refund. I now get to wait to see if Amazon will approve the claim.
ReplyDeleteApologies to Mr. Wetter for aiding these scumbags in stealing his work for their grubby little criminal hands.
I was so looking forward to offering this AT-AT 5-piece to my son for a "you got into College!" gift. Too good to be true ... is. I should have known better.
Thanks for your comment and for sharing your case. I hope it helps to forward this article, I can only do so much. I had a talks with a lawyer the other day, but since they have no physical address and the company and the distributor most likely are residing in China or maybe on the moon, it is hard for even company-lawyers to get and catch them. That is the reason this article is the only help here right now in the hope that others are warned at least.
DeleteI don´t mind if someone else gets the money for my art - that is business, in many legally perfect contracts, the artist gets tiny royalties while others rake in the benefits;) In this case it had however publicity effect that I could have not afforded otherwise - I only hoped they could have fulfilled the demand they created, that would have at least not left such a bad aftertaste for many.
I have a similar experience. I ordered the piece shown on Teepeat.com I got an order confirmation email and a shipping email with a working tracking number but I have had that for over a week and the tracking info still says its being prepared to ship. I got an email from them saying they cancelled my order and when I inquired why and that I had not requested a cancellation I got an email back saying it was an error and it had not been canceled and was actually shipped already. My credit card still has not been charged but after reading this I don't have any real expectation of getting the piece.
ReplyDeleteI ordered a pullover on this website and i feel so stupid. Never came and it's been two months. is there anything i can do to get my money back? they don't answer my messeges, neither comments which got worse cause they all get deleted.
ReplyDeleteIt depends; If you purchased via PayPal you have 90 days to claim a refund if you can send a proof that you not have received anything or if you believe it is counterfeit/ fraudulent offer. I believe their name is in a red list on Amazon and Paypal.
DeleteHowever, I have not heard yet from anyone having successfully getting a refund. But it also could be because in the pre-holiday season, PayPal also has a lot to do. I´ll keep an eye on that and update the article as soon as I hear anything about that matter. GL
damn it.. I got scammed too..! outrageous.. now i feel i was so naive. Didn't even bothered doing a little research before. Just ordered quickly cuz i needed it for Christmas!
ReplyDeleteSomeone is laughing now, while drinking a cocktail in some random exotic island!
I have the same problem. I ordered a canvas print in November, never received confirmation email or an order #. Yet I did receive an email from them with a 10% off coupon thanking me for my previous order. They charged my account in November. But so far I have not received the item, nor have I been able to contact anyone at the company. I tried emailing them and going to their facebook page with no response. I do not have an order # or tracking # to try on the website, but it sounds like it doesn't work anyway. My bank (USAA) is refunding my $168 as a disputed charge and will be attempting to contact the company themselves to recover the funds. If you have an awesome bank like I do, you might try that route.
ReplyDeleteVery useful blogpost. Thank you. Found a canvas on teepeat.com that I was about to order but just had a feeling something was a bit off. Wish i would have been wrong.
ReplyDeleteGuess I´ll just haveto keep looking, to bad since i just managed to convince my wife that a stormtrooper would fit in perfectly over the couch =)
Thanks again.
Best regards
nortish@gmail.com
So I fell for this as well. After 2 weeks of nothing I searched and came upon this page as well as pages upon pages of complaints under their advertisements on Facebook. They dated back months and all were the same issue. Ordered and didn't receive their product. I sent them an email saying I wanted to cancel, and after a week got nothing. I then filed a complaint through PayPal. I had a refund message within an hour. The money was in my PayPal account today and I transferred it to my account today. Hopefully by Tuesday next week it will be in my bank.
ReplyDeleteI also filed a complaint to Facebook about both Prime Line and Teepeat. I pointed to this page and told of what I had seen in their posts about complaints. I haven't seen it spam on my feed since. Hopefully others don't fall for this and it stays off of my feed.
Got scammed too it seems. Thank god I paid with amazon payments they have a-z buyer protection so I'll get my money back after they're done looking into it!
ReplyDeleteIts been over a month for me. Ordered off of prime line gear, and nothing has shown up at my door step. Got charged tho. Tried to track the order and it says that it dosent excist. Tried to check the website and it says to come back later. This sucks.
ReplyDeleteThey actually have multiple websites that look exactly the same but with different names such as PrimeLineGear, Teepeat,PrintApollo, and PrintGlaze. After reading your article, I was very suspicious of this retailer and noticed they don't even have any kind of customer support information which is very shady. But I really love the way the piece looks so I decided to take the risk and purchase it anyway. Luckily for me, the 5-piece canvas arrived in less than 3 weeks which is impressive considering the tracking info shows that it was sent from China. I'm sorry that the artist isn't getting credit for his work and it's likely that Disney didn't consent to the use of the Star Wars license either. I'm happy with the merchandise I received but I would recommend everyone take caution when making these kinds of purchases.
ReplyDeleteHi
ReplyDeleteI have ordered items from Prime Line on 25th October in the order of over $200. Until know I have not received any items and have no reply to emails, facebook messages or even calls to a none existing phone number in California, all from Prime Line Gear.
Questions has anyone else experienced the same crap service from this fraudulent company and if so did they ever get their money back or any of their items??? Or more importantly get any contact from the company???
If anyone has had a reply from PrimeLine Gear please share the details so i can call or email them and offer them my special thanks for stealing my money.
Thanks Tim
timears@hotmail.com
Hi good people of the internet. I found this article too late:/
ReplyDeleteIn this video (In Norwegian) I recived my purchase. Unpacking around 03.40:
https://www.facebook.com/oskarlure/videos/1794092857509955/
-Oskar
Hey Oskar, thanks for sharing your video. Are there stretcher bars at least? It seems it is a Do-it-yourself image. Sorry, don't understand the language. If you can explain a bit more in a comment, I guess that would help others as well.
DeleteThanks and best regards,
Oliver
This is a terrible company! I placed an order back in November and no one knows what is going on with it?! This is absolutely ridiculous and unacceptable! I WANT MY REFUND!!!!!! I should have read what everyone else wrote, you steal money from people giving them false promises of products!
ReplyDeleteI ordered 2 sets from teepeat just before xmas, I only ordered the canvas sets and they arrived yesterday direct from china. I'll make up the wooden boxes myself as cheaper than shipping them
ReplyDeleteI ordered this (with your artwork) from Prime Line on Black Friday 2016 and have yet to receive them (it's February). Now I know why! Time to try and get a refund...
ReplyDeleteI just wrote my credit card bank about this and they got the money back. If you payed by credit card, just contact your bank!
ReplyDeleteI order this on February, I deeply regret ordering this. I wish I did some research before this order!
ReplyDeleteI received the package (the trim was terrible), very strong smell, but also, one of the posters was wrong. Not only that, after that my credit card started to be misused and I had to cancel it and now I am claiming the money back. It has been a terrible idea!!!
This has been a hugely valuable blog; I FINALLY got my refund, from my order of the AT-AT, back in November. They kept using stall tactics, and offering partial refunds, e.g. "sorry, we have been tremendously back-ordered, for this piece; how about a 3% discount?" Eventually, they just completely stopped responding, and I filed a claim, with Amazon. This was honestly a beautiful piece though; I had the perfect spot for it, and it would have been my first purchase, of a piece of artwork. I even got some recessed lighting, to accentuate/compliment it, if I had ever gotten it.
ReplyDeleteWow....... On Instagram I got an ad for a sword art online canvas I wanted to get for my room for Christmas. It was my first time online shopping and I thought Instagram would be safe cause it's on my live feed. Now after a month or so without anything I saw this blog. I feel so stupid and I used a visa gift card people donated to me because I was flooded by Hurricane Harvey. I don't even know if I can get a refund and I know I can't really bring judicial justice into this cause I'm only 15. All I can hope is that I at least get what I paid for in the future.
ReplyDeleteHi, it is still possible that you will receive your order, but since most of these shops use "dropshipping" your product will be sent to you directly from China and depending on carrier that can take between 3 weeks and 3 months. In other comments of this blogpost, people have been able to successfully refund by talking to the bank accountant or credit card companies and declare the order as "fraud". Don't feel bad for it because others (and a lot older people too) fall victim to scammers because there are so many of them now out there. And that is why I believe this blog is so important. In the future I will work on follow-up posts also making artists aware of their powers against these shops.
DeleteLet me know how your case works out, cheers, Oliver